Iceland: What Went Wrong
I was recently contacted by a Journalist from Sydney's newspaper, The Daily Telegraph. He wanted me to write an article for the paper about what went wrong in Iceland that lead to the economic collapse. Below is the article I wrote:
As an Australian woman living in Iceland, I have witnessed first-hand Iceland's spectacular economic demise. So what went wrong? Well if you ask the business tycoons, bankers, politicians or other governing bodies, they will point the finger outward and say "it wasn’t me!"
There were a number of contributing factors that led to Iceland's remarkable economic collapse - An outsized banking system that was insufficiently regulated; an inappropriate monetary policy; and a political system of institutionalized corruption and self-enrichment.
The Government privatized and sold the banks to those who had close connections with the dominant parties and politicians. The whole process was orchestrated to ensure the bank stakes fell into "appropriate hands," however ownership went to people who had little experience in modern banking.
Bankers, politicians, regulators, top officials of the government and the central bank, were all inter-connected, therefore grossly undermining independence and adequate regulation of the banking and financial system. People in positions of power were typically chosen based on their political background and "connections" rather than their economic or financial expertise. Most notable of course was David Oddsson, Iceland's longest-serving prime minister, who later became governor of the Central Bank. With no economic or financial qualifications, Mr Oddsson was clearly ill-equipped to manage the Central Bank, let alone deal with an economic crisis.
And what did all this mean? There were a bunch of incompetent, corrupt people running the nation, whose primary motivation was to line their own pockets rather than serve the nation.
David Oddsson and the Central Bank pursued a monetary policy targeting inflation, thereby raising interest rates if inflation was above the target and lowering them if inflation was below the target. Whilst such a policy has a sound foundation in economic theory and is often appropriate for large countries, in the case of Iceland, it was disastrous.
Throughout the period of inflation targeting, inflation was above its target rate, resulting in considerable interest rate hikes. High interest rates encouraged people to borrow in foreign currency and it also brought large inflows of foreign currency, as financiers would borrow money in low interest countries such as Japan and then lend it to banks, companies and individuals in Iceland at higher interest rates. The difference between the two interest rates was pocketed as profit.
In less than a decade, Iceland became a financial giant. Banks and companies borrowed heavily to fund investments both in Iceland and abroad, racking up foreign assets worth around 10 times the Icelandic GDP, with debts to match. In normal economic circumstances this is not a cause for worry, so long as the banks are prudently run. However, the Icelandic banks were being run by people with little experience in modern banking. These people focused aggressively on the short-term maximization of profits and lucrative bonus payments, without regard for the sustainability and longevity of the financial system. The problem was that the Icelandic banks had created an illusion of wealth, although in reality, they had a very high level of leverage (i.e. debt to real assets).
The Icelandic Central Bank gave up reserve requirements and tried to curb the rising inflation caused by the financial boom by increasing interest rates as high as 18%, however this just led to a greater influx of foreign capital, and further boom.
Whilst Iceland's bankers and politicians were busy gloating over their economic prowess and lining their pockets with huge salaries and bonuses, it was clear to many well-known international economists that the system was unsustainable and that a collapse was inevitable. On a number of occasions, economic experts (some as far back as 2007) warned the government, central bank and financial sector of the imminent collapse, however this fell on deaf ears. The governing bodies completely dismissed these repeated warnings, instead turning a blind eye while the bankers continued on their ruthless and destructive path toward financially ruining this nation. But of course, as predicted, the bubble burst in October 2008 and the country's banks collapsed under the weight of an unsustainable foreign debt. As one local put so well, "we should have turned the music down when the party got out of hand." Yes, its one hell of a hangover and the average hard-working Icelander is now heavily paying the price (and so will their grandchildren).
Iceland is a small society where a small number of inter-connected individuals are responsible for deciding on everything that is important, therefore making it the perfect breeding ground for corruption. It was recently brought to light that the government of the Independence Party and Social Democrats accepted over 70 million ISK in the last campaign year from Landsbankinn and the controlling owners of Glitnir (FL Group), when it was considered normal to accept donations of 300,000 - 500,000 ISK. How can the government intervene or rein in the banks after receiving such lucrative donations?
It was also during this same scandal, that one of the Independence Party members had publicly declared he was aware of who was responsible for accepting the large donations within his party, however he would not reveal their identity as his loyalty lay with the party. This statement enraged me! A politician's loyalty should never lie with its party – their loyalty should always lie with the nation and its people. Politicians are elected by the people for the people. They are trusted to act in their best interests of the nation.
Iceland's small society of cross-ownership and inter-connected relationships has also brought with it a "code of silence." People are afraid to speak out because unless you are wired into the "right" political party and/or the right business blocks, it may become difficult to get ahead. Even the mainstream media channels in Iceland are governed by a certain few prominent business moguls, thereby grossly undermining the fair and independent reporting of news.
To this day, the blame game of who is responsible for this colossal economic disaster continues. No-one has accepted responsibility. No-one has been held accountable. No-one has apologized for their blatant incompetence or their aggressive self-enrichment practices at the expense of the nation. In other countries, politicians and people in positions of power are held accountable for the slightest misdemeanors, such as having to make a public apology for a speeding or drink driving offence. Here in Iceland however, those rules clearly do not apply. Quite frankly, it has left me feeling appalled and disgusted.
Since the economic collapse, it has been estimated that each day there are approximately ten businesses going bankrupt in Iceland. The three major banks have already been nationalized, and the state is acquiring more and more companies as the bankrupt domino effect continues. Given that no-one has taken responsibility for the country's economic collapse and that no-one has been held accountable, people are afraid the institutionalized corruption will continue. People are afraid that it may only be a matter of time before history repeats itself, with the Friendly Privatization (Part Two) taking place.
The Icelandic people are angry and frustrated about what has gone on here, and they are anxious about the future. However, there is a glimmer of hope and optimism on the horizon. With the recent change of Government to the coalition of the Social Democrats and the Left Greens, Icelanders are hopeful that changes may come. The leaders of this nation must now step up to the plate and restore the nation's faith and trust in the political and economic system.
No comments:
Post a Comment